US National Smore Day
<p>In 1927, a Girl Scout handbook called <em>Tramping and Trailing with the Girl Scouts</em> printed a campfire recipe under the plain heading “Some More”. It called for eight roasting sticks, sixteen graham crackers, eight chocolate bars broken in two, and sixteen marshmallows, and instructed scouts to toast two marshmallows “to a crisp gooey state” and press them, with the chocolate, between the crackers. That recipe is the earliest definitive record of the treat now eaten on 10 August, US National S’more Day, when Americans gather around fires to assemble the graham-cracker, marshmallow and chocolate sandwich whose contracted name, “s’more”, is a worn-down version of that 1927 heading.</p>
<h2 id="a-recipe-with-a-real-source-and-a-fake-author">A recipe with a real source and a fake author</h2><div class="ad-unit ad-in-article" aria-label="Advertisement">
<span class="ad-label">Advertisement</span>
<ins class="adsbygoogle" style="display:block;text-align:center"
data-ad-client="ca-pub-3726833845844946"
data-ad-slot="3291553914"
data-ad-format="auto"
data-full-width-responsive="true"></ins>
<script>(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});</script>
</div>
<p>The 1927 handbook is genuine, and it is the firm anchor of the s’more’s history; the publication exists and the recipe is in it under the name “Some More”. The name itself is a small joke about appetite, the implication being that anyone who ate one would immediately ask for some more, and over the following decades the phrase wore down in speech to the single contracted word we use now.</p>
<p>What is not genuine is the inventor most often credited. For years the recipe was attributed to a troop leader named Loretta Scott Crew, a name that circulated widely and even acquired its own encyclopaedia entry. The trouble is that no one can find any evidence she existed. Shannon Browning-Mullis, a historian for Girl Scouts of the USA, has stated plainly that “we could not find any mention of her”, and the supposed inventor appears to be a hoax that propagated through the internet until it was treated as fact and her entry deleted. The honest position is that the s’more has a documented first recipe and no documented first author. Someone at a campfire combined three ingredients that were already commonplace; the handbook simply wrote it down.</p>
<p>Each of those three ingredients had its own separate arrival. The graham cracker descends from the dietary reformer Sylvester Graham, a Presbyterian minister in 1830s Connecticut who promoted coarse, unsifted wholemeal flour as part of a temperate, vegetarian regime; the plain “graham” biscuit named after him was, ironically, supposed to be an austere health food rather than the base of a sugary dessert. The marshmallow began as a French confection, <em>pâte de guimauve</em>, whisked from the sap of the marsh-mallow plant, and was being mass-produced in the United States by the 1900s once the plant sap gave way to gelatine. Milk chocolate in convenient bar form was, by 1927, cheap and ubiquitous thanks to Milton Hershey’s Pennsylvania factory. The s’more, in other words, could only have appeared once all three industrial sweets had become everyday pantry items — which is exactly why a 1920s scouting manual is the plausible moment for someone to write it down.</p>
<h2 id="why-the-day-matters">Why the day matters</h2>
<p>National S’more Day is less about the food than about the setting the food requires. You cannot, in the original conception, make a s’more without a fire, and the fire brings everything else: the outdoors, the dark, the people gathered close to the heat, the unhurried business of toasting a marshmallow to the colour you prefer. The treat is an excuse for an evening rather than the point of one, which is unusual for a food holiday.</p>
<p>That hands-on quality is the heart of its appeal. A s’more is partly a thing you make and partly a thing you do, and the making, threading the marshmallow, turning it patiently over the coals, pressing the hot result against the chocolate until it softens, is half the pleasure. It is a dessert built around a small ritual, which is why it crosses generations so easily and why it sits comfortably among the simpler shared-pleasure observances of the summer calendar, near the campfire cousins like <a href="/specialdate/us-national-pots-de-creme-day/">National Pots de Crème Day</a> and the regional sweet-tooth entries such as <a href="/specialdate/us-national-spumoni-day/">National Spumoni Day</a>.</p>
<h2 id="how-the-day-is-kept">How the day is kept</h2><div class="ad-unit ad-in-article" aria-label="Advertisement">
<span class="ad-label">Advertisement</span>
<ins class="adsbygoogle" style="display:block;text-align:center"
data-ad-client="ca-pub-3726833845844946"
data-ad-slot="3291553914"
data-ad-format="auto"
data-full-width-responsive="true"></ins>
<script>(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});</script>
</div>
<p>On 10 August, the celebration is reassuringly literal: build a fire, or a fire pit, or fall back on a barbecue, and make s’mores. The classic method holds, a marshmallow skewered and held over the flames until it turns golden and gooey, then sandwiched with a square of chocolate between two graham crackers, the residual heat melting the chocolate just enough. For those without a fire, an oven grill or even a microwave produces a passable version, which has helped the treat migrate from the campsite into ordinary kitchens.</p>
<p>The format invites tinkering. Enthusiasts swap dark chocolate for milk, or peanut-butter cups for plain bars, trade graham crackers for digestive biscuits or shortbread, and slip in fruit, caramel or flavoured marshmallows. The argument over how dark a marshmallow should be toasted, lightly bronzed versus deliberately set alight and blown out, is a genuine and good-natured division among s’more makers. Sharing the results is half the point, and the experimentation is part of the day’s spirit.</p>
<h2 id="beyond-the-campfire">Beyond the campfire</h2>
<p>The s’more is so strongly American that its spread elsewhere tends to come through that association rather than through any native tradition. But the underlying idea, toasted marshmallow against chocolate, travels easily, and versions have followed American campers, films and franchises abroad. The graham cracker is the sticking point: it is a distinctly American biscuit, so cooks elsewhere substitute digestives in Britain or other plain sweet biscuits, quietly localising the sandwich while keeping its shape.</p>
<p>What does not vary is the requirement for fire and company. A s’more made alone in a kitchen is a snack; a s’more made at a fire with other people is the thing the day actually celebrates. The treat resists being fully industrialised precisely because so much of its value is in the circumstances of its making, which no packaged version can supply.</p>
<p>That has not stopped manufacturers trying. There are s’more-flavoured cereals, ice creams, coffee syrups and breakfast bars, and Hershey has built marketing campaigns around the bar’s natural fit between two crackers, going so far as to mould some chocolate bars into segments that snap to the right size. Microwave kits and dedicated electric s’more makers exist for the firepit-deprived. The flavour profile — toasted sugar, melted chocolate, a faint biscuit crunch — has effectively become a stand-alone idea, sold in products that never touch a flame. It is a curious afterlife for a recipe that was, at heart, an instruction for what to do with a campfire and a few cheap sweets.</p>
<h2 id="what-the-smore-stands-for">What the s’more stands for</h2>
<p>The s’more has become shorthand for a particular kind of evening: summer, the outdoors, a fire shared among friends, stories told while marshmallows char. The contrast of textures, crisp cracker, melting chocolate, soft toasted marshmallow, is the sensory signature, but the cultural weight sits in the setting rather than the flavour. It is one of the few desserts whose symbolism is more about where and with whom you eat it than what it tastes like.</p>
<p>There is also a streak of deliberate simplicity in it. Three cheap, common ingredients and a source of heat are all it asks, and that accessibility is the reason it spread from a 1927 scouting manual to back gardens everywhere. A dessert anyone can make with what is already in the cupboard, requiring only a flame and a few minutes, has a democratic appeal that more elaborate sweets cannot match.</p>
<h2 id="fun-facts">Fun facts</h2>
<ul>
<li>The first definitive s’more recipe appeared in the 1927 Girl Scout handbook <em>Tramping and Trailing with the Girl Scouts</em>, under the name “Some More”.</li>
<li>That original recipe specified exact quantities: eight sticks, sixteen graham crackers, eight chocolate bars broken in two, and sixteen marshmallows.</li>
<li>The treat’s long-credited inventor, “Loretta Scott Crew”, appears to be a hoax; Girl Scouts of the USA’s own historian could find no evidence she ever existed.</li>
<li>The word “s’more” is a contraction of “some more”, a built-in joke about how quickly one leads to wanting another.</li>
<li>The graham cracker is distinctly American, so s’mores made abroad routinely substitute digestives or other plain biscuits.</li>
<li>Its three components arrived separately: the graham cracker from 1830s health reformer Sylvester Graham, the marshmallow from a French confection, and cheap milk chocolate from Milton Hershey’s factory — the treat could only exist once all three were everyday items.</li>
</ul>
<h2 id="a-closing-reflection">A closing reflection</h2>
<p>It is oddly fitting that the s’more has a precisely documented recipe and an entirely fictional inventor. The combination is too simple to need an author; it is the kind of thing countless scouts and campers would have stumbled onto independently around a fire, and the 1927 handbook caught it rather than created it. The invented Loretta Scott Crew was an attempt to give a faceless tradition a face, which says something about how much we want our small pleasures to have a clear origin. The s’more refuses to provide one, and is no less beloved for it, asking only for a fire, three ingredients, and someone to share the next one with.</p>
Advertisement
Related Content
Advertisement
